Today, between Ticino and Italy, it's no longer just the football hierarchy that matters: in the delicate management of the geographical and cultural proximity that characterizes our inevitable… border promiscuity, political, economic, and social factors are increasingly being introduced, further complicating a relationship that, despite what we have in common, tends to highlight—sometimes not without palpable, growing intolerance—what makes us different.
To the point of prompting some legitimate reflection on the nature of certain thorny issues that have recently emerged at both the institutional and media levels, which have contributed to extending and even changing the characteristics of a proximity in which exchange very often turns into confrontation. The roundtable discussion we dedicated to this highly topical and interesting topic, with its myriad facets, could not fail to highlight the various perspectives from which it is possible, indeed necessary, to attempt to analyze the foundational quality of a bond that certainly deserves to be protected and preserved. Today's Ticino, moreover, is historically the product of a significant migratory flow from Italy, which has generated a significant portion of what has become its very social fabric. Who we are, in short, also depends, inevitably, on who we have been: denying it, or even simply attempting to reduce its influence, would risk biasing any attempt at analysis incompletely, to say the least.

Already in the preparation phase of the evening—attended by a large and highly engaged audience in the welcoming RIVADUE space of Palazzo Mantegazza—we took this into account, inviting personalities with personal histories particularly in tune with the topic of discussion, such as Stefania Padoan, a Treviso-born entrepreneur who heads the family business now firmly established in our region, straddling Lugano and the Grisons, and Stefano Rogna, CEO of Banca Sempione, a neighbor from Valtellina, now a Swiss citizen who has put down roots in Ticino. In some ways, their approach was the most spontaneous and meaningful: both fully aware of the transformations of recent years, they nevertheless made a point of emphasizing in their presentations the strength of the bond they have established with a region and a community that, despite everything, maintains enormous potential for attractiveness and growth.
Bernardino Regazzoni, Swiss ambassador to Rome at the end of the era of banking secrecy, undoubtedly experienced firsthand one of the most turbulent periods in relations between Ticino and Italy. For a Ticinese active in Swiss diplomacy in many different contexts, representing our country in the very capital of that Italian identity to which we too—like it or not—unquestionably belong, may not have been easy. Or perhaps not? "You'll be like a fish in water," he heard from a colleague who had preceded him in the experience he now recalls as one of the most important, but not necessarily the most difficult, of his long career.
The ambassador's role, Regazzoni pointed out, isn't to intervene directly in operational matters but rather to facilitate relations between the various actors involved in each issue involving their respective governments. And in the end, did he find himself...just like a fish in water? "I had a great time, of course."
A feeling entirely in tune with the one expressed by the Italian Consul General in Lugano, Uberto Vanni d'Archirafi, who offered the debate with extreme clarity and precision, contributing his experience of living and working in Ticino. He focused primarily on the overall volume and therefore the overall value of the relationship between the Canton and Italy, which cannot be undermined by specific issues such as the feared freeze on cross-border commuter refunds. This was the issue that ultimately constituted… the real elephant in the room, unavoidable, of course, but one that should be addressed with due calm and without underestimating its political impact and potential consequences for the Bern-Rome axis.
A new and insidious dimension of the privileged relationship between Bellinzona and Italy, in which the resounding and extraordinary uniqueness of the exclusive sharing of a language and, by extension, a cultural heritage—which makes the spread of our language practically unique in the world—is dissolved into the rivulets of international politics, made up of agreements, protocols, and practices agreed upon, accepted, and respected by the parties. And which, in effect, elevates the problem to a higher level, creating a situation of undeniable unease between Bern and Rome, and, inevitably, cascading between Bellinzona and Bern.
But then, perhaps against the backdrop of the Crans-Montana tragedy, which we deliberately chose not to include in the map of the new Italian-Swiss cross-border reciprocity, but which nevertheless occasionally intruded into the guests' reflections, almost as if to certify a different approach and interpretation, is there really a risk that this uneasy situation felt by the Canton could cause a real rift with the Confederation, which for its part is concerned with protecting the best interests of the relationship with Italy?
From a strictly economic perspective, Andrea Gehri, from his vantage point as President of the Ticino Chamber of Commerce, urged a careful and realistic consideration of the true scale of the sums at stake for Ticino's finances: over one hundred million francs, which, given the current economic situation, would be of significant importance to the canton's coffers. Is this a smaller-scale prospect—one that had already surfaced during the negotiations that led to the agreement between Italy and Switzerland, about which Ticino had expressed its concerns—or a justified attempt to reiterate the criticality of a very different scenario from the general one?
It's difficult to predict how this will end: the stalemate appears, in some ways, even embarrassing, more so domestically than internationally, where, as Giangi Cretti, Director of the Journal of the Italian Chamber of Commerce for Switzerland and a longtime contributor to our country, aptly noted, the parameters and thus the sensitivities are not comparable to local perceptions. Certainly, what has always been seen as a controversial relationship, to say the least, typical perhaps of those who are more similar to the other side than they are willing and unable to accept, currently appears to be nearing an all-time low in understanding and cooperation: Ticino appears unwilling to back down, Swiss political culture does not foresee a decisive intervention from Bern, and the dispute over cross-border workers is not a priority for Italy.
The real crux, likely, lies precisely in this combination of misalignments, which will have to be resolved one way or another. To return to the old, harmless misunderstandings that have shaped the history of a frontier that is more political than cultural.









